Hare Krishna

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON), popularly known as the Hare Krishna movement, is a Gaudiya Vaishnavism tradition founded by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada in 1966. The movement emphasises devotion to Krishna, promoting bhakti yoga and community living. In Australia, ISKCON operates several temples and centres, playing a significant role in the spiritual landscape. Applying Renee’s Cult Ranking System, we will evaluate ISKCON’s operations in Australia, focusing on whether they exhibit controlling or cult-like behaviours.

1. Authoritative Leadership

Score: 2

ISKCON in Australia follows a hierarchical structure where spiritual leaders and gurus hold significant influence. Although leadership is respected for its spiritual guidance, this authority is generally accepted by members willingly. However, the deference to leadership and the expectation to follow the teachings of A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada and current gurus can create a strong authoritative dynamic

2. Control Over Information

Score: 2

ISKCON emphasises studying its founder's texts and teachings. While members have access to various religious resources, there is a strong focus on the specific interpretations provided by ISKCON. This can limit exposure to alternative viewpoints within the broader Vaishnavism tradition and other spiritual perspectives. Members are encouraged to adhere to the teachings and literature approved by ISKCON

3. Deception

Score: 1

ISKCON is generally transparent about its beliefs, practices, and objectives. Public outreach often includes chanting, literature distribution, and community services. While there have been criticisms about aggressive recruitment tactics and fundraising methods in the past, ISKCON's activities in Australia today appear more open and clear about their intentions.

4. Exclusive Knowledge

Score: 2

ISKCON promotes its path as the most direct way to spiritual enlightenment and Krishna consciousness. This emphasis on the unique validity of its teachings can create a sense of exclusive spiritual knowledge. While the movement encourages study and understanding, it tends to prioritise its interpretations over others within the broader Hindu and spiritual landscape.

5. Exploitation

Score: 2

ISKCON requires significant dedication from its members, including time, financial contributions, and lifestyle changes. Members are often encouraged to participate actively in temple activities, fundraising, and community services. While many participate voluntarily out of devotion, the demands on members can be intensive and sometimes perceived as exploitative, especially for those living in ISKCON communities.

6. Fear, Guilt, & Intimidation

Score: 1

ISKCON generally promotes a positive and devotional environment. However, there is an implicit pressure to conform to the group’s standards and lifestyle. Members may experience guilt or fear of spiritual failure if they deviate from the prescribed practices or question the leadership. This dynamic can create an environment where emotional and spiritual pressure influences behaviour.

7. Isolation

Score: 2

Members of ISKCON, especially those living in temple communities, may experience a degree of social isolation from the broader society. The movement encourages a lifestyle centred around Krishna consciousness, which can limit interaction with non-members. This separation is less pronounced for congregational members who live outside the temple but still maintain a distinct religious and social identity.

8. Micro-Management of Daily Tasks

Score: 2

ISKCON’s lifestyle includes specific routines and practices, such as regular chanting, attending temple services, and adhering to a strict diet. While these practices are part of the spiritual discipline, they can also lead to detailed management of members’ daily lives, particularly for those deeply involved in temple activities or living within the community.

9. Monitoring Thoughts & Behaviours

Score: 2

ISKCON places a strong emphasis on adherence to its spiritual practices and beliefs. Members’ behaviours and spiritual progress are often closely observed, especially within temple communities. This monitoring aims to ensure compliance with the movement's standards and can create a sense of surveillance and pressure to conform to expected norms.

10. Punishment & Discipline

Score: 1

ISKCON employs relatively mild disciplinary measures, focusing on spiritual guidance and community support to address non-compliance. However, deviations from prescribed practices or questioning authority can lead to social ostracism or spiritual counselling. The emphasis is generally on correction and reintegration rather than harsh punishment.

11. Thought Reform

Score: 2

The movement engages in thought reform through its intense focus on devotional practices and teachings. Members are encouraged to internalise ISKCON’s interpretations and lifestyle as central to their identity and spiritual progress. This process, while not overtly coercive, involves significant indoctrination into the group’s specific worldview.

12. Us vs. Them Mentality

Score: 2

ISKCON fosters a strong sense of community and identity centred around Krishna consciousness. This can lead to a subtle “us vs. them” mentality, distinguishing devout members from the broader secular society. While this division is generally not antagonistic, it reinforces a distinct separation between the ISKCON community and those outside its beliefs.

​

Total Score: 21/36

​

Overall Cult Ranking: 6. Cult

​

With an overall score of 6 on Renee’s scale, ISKCON in Australia is categorised as a “Cult.” This ranking indicates that while ISKCON fosters a structured and dedicated spiritual environment, there are aspects of control and conformity that can exert significant influence over its members. The group’s practices promote a strong sense of community and devotion, but they also involve elements of control over personal beliefs and behaviours.

ISKCON in Australia, as evaluated through Renee’s Cult Ranking System, reflects a movement with deep spiritual commitments and structured practices. While it provides a supportive and vibrant community for its members, the elements of control and expectation warrant careful consideration for those involved or interested in the movement. 

Understanding these dynamics helps in navigating personal spiritual paths and making informed decisions about involvement in religious communities.

​

Further Reading

• Authoritarian Culture and Child Abuse in ISKCON

• Hare Krishna Melbourne

• I Road-Tested Three Cults Around Melbourne